SEO Advice

Ahrefs DR4 update exposes what your cheap DR70 backlinks were really worth

Want to buy a backlink? Bold text on pink paper debunking the myth that high dr70 backlinks are actually worth your hard-earned cash.
Non-Wanky SEO

You’ve had the email. I’ve had the email. Everyone has had the fucking email.

“Hi! We have high authority DR70 guest post sites available. Only $25 per link. Spreadsheet attached.” The spreadsheet is 400 rows long. Every site on it has a name like “best business tips hub”. And there’s a bulk discount if you order before Friday.

Another seo spammer promising page-one rankings for £49. The caption says fictional email. Familiar bullshit. Because as if that’s ever going to happen.

On 1 December, Ahrefs changes how it works out Domain Rating. A LOT of those DR70 sites are about to find out what their number was made of. So is everyone who bought links from them.

What is the Ahrefs DR4 update?

Domain Rating (DR) is Ahrefs’ score for how strong a website’s backlinks are. Glen Allsopp at Ahrefs announced DR4 on 5 November, and it replaces the old score on 1 December.

The big change is that a link only counts properly now if the site it comes from gets organic search traffic. Sites that exist purely to sell links don’t pass on much at all (no readers, no visitors, just a “get a link” page and a PayPal button).

Subdomains also get their own score now instead of borrowing the main domain’s. That’s how a free notion.site page used to sit at DR 92. Under DR4 it’s DR 0.

Zero.

Why DR70 link sellers are about to be exposed

Normal websites barely move. Of the top 1,000 sites by traffic, 64% went up. The ones that dropped lost a median of 4 points.

What about sites Ahrefs labels as spam that scored between DR 30 and 70? They dropped by a median of 15 to 20 points.

Directories got hammered. Botmonster ran 359 SaaS launch directories through DR4 and 335 of them dropped. Before the change, 68 of them scored DR 70 or more. Now it’s 18. One went from 71 to 3.7.

Mark Williams-Cook said it best in his Core Updates newsletter this week: if you’ve been buying links because “it’s DR 70”, December is going to show you what that DR was really made of.

Domain Rating is not a Google ranking factor

I’ll keep saying this for as long as it takes. DR is a number Ahrefs made up.

It’s a handy way to compare link profiles inside Ahrefs, and that’s it. Every tool has its own version: Moz has Domain Authority (which came first), Semrush has Authority Score, and each one gives the same website a different number. Google doesn’t use any of them. Google’s John Mueller has said so for years, most bluntly in 2022, when he said it doesn’t use domain authority ‘at all’.

DR4 proves the point better than I ever could. A website can be DR 70 on 30 November and DR 40 on 1 December without a single thing about it changing. Only the formula changed.

So when someone sells you a link “because it’s DR 70”, what you’re buying is a third-party number that’s easy to pump up and easy to stick in a sales email. Your rankings don’t come into it.

What 100 cheap backlinks a month did for one web designer’s SEO

A couple of years ago, a client came to me who’d signed up for one of these packages: 100 backlinks a month, for $20 a month. That’s 20 cents a link.

I get it. It sounds like a bargain, and the seller had a page full of big DR numbers to prove it.

It did nothing for her rankings.

Nothing. At. All.

What it did do was fill her backlink profile with porn sites, gambling sites, and link farm directories with names like “TopLinkz4U”. Anyone who looked her up in an SEO tool saw the lot, and that included potential clients.

She was a web designer. Her whole pitch was “I’ll make your business look professional online”. Casino links were not helping.

Nobody wants to be linked to from a porn site, whatever the DR says. (I mean, that’s not strictly true, of course, I’m sure some website owners would be happy…)

How to check a website’s DR4 score before 1 December

If you’ve bought links, or someone’s trying to sell you some, you can check the new scores now. Ahrefs’ free Domain Rating API shows DR4 if you add version=dr4, and there’s a DR4 demo page where you can search any domain.

If you (or your agency) report on DR, screenshot it before 1 December, so when the number moves you can show everyone why.

Better still, forget the number. Does the site linking to you get real visitors? Would you be happy for a prospect to click through and see it? If not, the DR is irrelevant.

What good backlinks look like for a small B2B business

The links that help a small B2B site are usually a bit boring, and you’ve probably already got the relationships for them. Your suppliers and partners can list you. Your trade association has a member directory. The local paper in Kettering might cover a new contract. A podcast in your industry might want you as a guest, or a client might write up the work you did together.

None of those come with a DR on the invoice, because there isn’t an invoice. They’re real sites with real readers, which is exactly what DR4 has supposedly started rewarding.

I went through the link building tactics that work for small businesses in episode 23 of the podcast, Stop Buying Backlinks FFS!, if you want the long version.

And next time an email offers you DR70 links for $25 a pop, ask them what those sites will score on 2 December.

If you’re not sure what’s sitting in your own backlink profile, or you’ve got one of those emails open in another tab right now, book an SEO 1:1. We’ll go through your links together and work out what’s worth keeping, what’s doing you no favours and what to do instead.

Nikki pilkington, rooftops and chunky boots. Sign up for 1:1 seo training for £200 + vat. No-nonsense advice, minus the usual marketing bollocks.
Occasionally sweary

Want more of this in your inbox?

News and views on SEO (and LinkedIn sometimes). Once a week, no waffle, no selling you a GEO course.

You know you're not allowed to unsubscribe because I swear, right?

GDPR Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner